Limiting the AC input of a Phoenix Smart Charger in parallel with a MultiPlus Compact

In a previous article I described the electric installation in our Toyota HiAce with a 24V battery and a Victron MultiPlus Compact 24/1600/40-16. At that point one piece was still missing: the Phoenix Smart IP43 Charger 24/25. It finally arrived this weekend and so it was time to install it; and configure it – which is normally not something worth going into lengthy detail.

However, in this case we wanted a kind of “special” setup which included the use of MultiPlus Assistants. So, in this article I will quickly describe what we wanted to achieve and how we implemented it.

In general, when connected to shore power we want to be able to limit the AC current drawn from the shore power. This is easily accomplished by setting a limit on the MultiPlus itself – or, as in our case, via the VE.Bus Smart Dongle. Though the Phoenix does have a VE.Direct interface and is able to be connected to a GX device, in our setup we did not want to use a GX device. So, essentially the Phoenix can only be controlled via Bluetooth and the VictronConnect app. But configuring the AC input limit on two devices (Phoenix and MultiPlus) is not only a nuisance from a usability standpoint, but also error-prone as one (or at least we) tend to forget things quickly. So, a different and better solution was needed.

Enter the MultiPlus Assistant in form of the Programmable Relay. With this, we can configure the built-in relay of the MultiPlus to open and close based on the availability of an AC input.

Note: we have to disable “Virtual Switch” in the MultiPlus to be able to use the MultiPlus Assistant.

The Phoenix has a Remote Input connector, that can be used to stop charging when the connection is “off”. So in our case, we enabled two Programmable Relay assistants:

  1. Programmable Relay, NC – On/Open
    After 5 seconds of AC input on the MultiPlus the relay is opened.
  2. Programmable Relay, NC – Off/Closed
    After 1 second of no AC input on the MultiPlus the relay is closed (which is the default state).

The wiring is as easy as to connect:

  • MultiPlus Relay COM < — > Phoenix Remote Input L
  • MultiPlus Relay NC < — > Phoenix Remote Input H

Note: on this page you find a description where the relay is located in the different MultiPlus models.

Below you find some screenshots with the configuration in VE Configure:

Disable Virtual Switch on MultiPlus
Add 2 Progammable Relay assistants
Programmable Relay ON after 5 seconds
Programmable Relay OFF after 1 second

So, five seconds after the MultiPlus has power via AC input it will open the relay which in turn will enable the Phoenix to start charging.

One second after AC input is gone the MultiPlus will close the relay so the Phoenix will stop charing (if it was charging at all).

The AC input of the Phoenix is connected to the AC output of the MultiPlus. So, when there is a AC input limit configured on the MultiPlus (such as 3A @230V) the MultiPlus and the Phoenix will not be able to charge with more than 3A. And from the MultiPlus perspective, the Phoenix is just an arbitrary consumer.

This can lead to some undesired behaviour if we were to limit the AC input to e.g. 1A. In this case, the MultiPlus would – when in Inverter mode – draw from the battery so the Phoenix could charge the battery. perpetuum mobile … ? And when the AC input is gone, this means that for roughly one second the Phoenix will also charge form the battery. But this is something I can live with easily.

And if we really had a very low power AC input (of e.g. 1A) we can still unplug the remote input and force the Phoenix not to charge. Or manually switch the MultiPlus to Charger mode only.

For us this is a usable solution without the need for multiple configuration changes nor the presence of a GX device.

Electric Installation in our Toyota HiAce 1994

Now, that we got our Toyota HiAce we thought it might be a good idea to add more power to the vehicle: in form of an 8s EVE LF280K LiFePO4 battery and a Victron MultiPlus Compact 24/1600/40-16 inverter/charger. In the following, we describe our setup and the reason why we built it like this.

The Requirements

  1. The sustained output power of the inverter must be over 1'200W.
  2. Charging via AC via EVSE or generator must be possible.
  3. Charging via alternator must be possible (but is not the norm).
  4. Charging of 60% of the battery (from 20% – 80%) via AC should take less than 180min.
  5. The installation should use the minimum amount of space possible.
  6. We should be able to use our existing Eve LF280K cells, thus limiting the overall current to 140A.
  7. As the vehicle will not have a diesel heater, it should be possible to run a 150W infrared heater for at least 3 * (4+2)h = 18h (^= 2'700Wh).
  8. In addition, the battery should be able to run a refrigerator with an average power consumption of 50W for at least 72h ^= 3'600Wh (next to other power consumption).

Design Considerations

  • With a maximum current of 140A and a cable run length of 1.5m, we should plan with a cross section of at least 35mm2.
  • Basically, with Eve LF280K cells we have three choices regarding the battery size:
    • 1* 4s (“12V”) Configuration
      4 * 3.2V * 280Ah = 3'584Wh
      This would lead to a required nominal AC charge power of at least 716.8W/h and a charge current of at least 56A/h.
    • 2* 4s (“12V”) Configuration
      2* 4 * 3.2V * 280Ah = 7'168Wh
      This would lead to a required nominal AC charge power of at least 1'433.6W/h and a charge current of at least 112A/h.
    • 1* 8s (“24V”) Configuration
      8 * 3.2V * 280Ah = 7'168Wh
      This would lead to a required nominal AC charge power of at least 1'433.6W/h and a charge current of at least 56A/h.
  • The Victron MultiPlus Compact xx/1600VA inverter/charger provides enough sustained power output (while being smaller than the non-Compact edition). Depending on the voltage of the battery, this will slightly impact the amount of charge current.
  • To charge the battery via the alternator we would need a DC/DC converter that depends on the battery configuration as well (either 12-12 or 12-24). So, let’s have a look at the battery first.

1* 4s (“12V”) Configuration

The smallest, lightest and cheapest configuration. But capacity requirements regarding the fridge are only fulfilled, if there are no other loads. In addition, the discharge current is relatively high (scratching the maximum discharge rate of 0.5C).

2* 4s (“12V”) Configuration

More complex setup, as each battery needs a separate BMS, which leads to the need of an aggregator for both batteries to correctly report SoC and calculate CCL and DCL. In addition, more cabling and fusing is required (and probably to a large bus bar). Comes with the advantage of having a redundant battery in case a single battery fails. Most expensive configuration.

1* 8s (“24V”) Configuration

Custom battery build needed, as there is not enough space for a typical 2 * 4 cells setup behind he seats. But, only a single BMS and thus less wiring is needed. Comes with a slight disadvantage of not having native 12V from the battery. This is actually not an isse, as all our DC devices also accept 24V. Cells can better balance voltage differences across a single 8s bank.

The Setup

In the end, I decided for the 8s configuration, due to less complexity. Splitting the 8s configuration across two cell blocks seemed to be an acceptable compromise.

As a regular MultiPlus 24/1600/40-16 would not fulfill my AC charge requirements, I had to decide to either add a second MultiPlus or to add a dedicated charger. I opted for a Phoenix Smart IP43 Charger 24/25 instead of a second MultiPlus. The MultiPlus in parallel would always consume 10W though most of the time I would not need the output power. Whereas, the Phoenix would only need power, when connected to AC. And reconfiguring the MultiPlus every time I charge was not an option for me. And yes, I lose redundancy – but also save some money (Phoenix is much cheaper). So, in the end the nominal charge power is 40A + 25A = 65A, which lets me charge at 1'560W reaching 60% within 165min.

The HiAce comes with a 70A alternator, so I chose a Orion-Tr Smart 12/24-15 DC-DC Charger. With this charger, I could run the engine in standby and still have the car heater running. And this is probably the predominant use case (if charging via alternator at all).

For the DC bus bar I went for a Victron Lynx Distributor, so I could use and install MEGA fuses. Having a 1’000A bus bar seems certainly overkill, but a separate bus bar and fuse box that accepts 35mm2 cable and MEGA fuses would be not be much smaller.

I changed the existing AC inlet of the HiAce to Neutrik PowerCON True1 TOP (congrats to the marketing department, I am still amazed how this name rolls of the tongue) and installed 2 Siemens compact 16A C RCBOs (external AC in, internal AC out). I am aware that theoretically I could support more than 16A on the internal AC out (via PowerAssist). If ever needed, I can replace the RCBO with a 20A version.

I added a VE.Bus Smart Dongle to the MultiPlus and opted against a complete (Raspberry-based) GX installation. The reason, I keep a USB MK3 with me anyway (in case I need to reconfigure the MultiPlus) and still have (Bluetooth) access to the most important settings and information of the MultiPlus. With the GX, I would to be running a WiFi hotspot (and consuming more energy as well). The disadvanage of not being able to use DVCC with information from the BMS is clear to me and accepted.

I selected a B2A8S20P JK-BMS that has an integrated 2A balancer and an RS485, CAN and heat port. In case, I ever add a GX device, I am still able to connect them and use DVCC.

The Specs

  • Nominal power (“capacity”)
    8 * 3.2V * 280Ah = 7'168Wh
  • Maximum discharge power 1’600VA (1'280W, capped by the inverter)
    with a maximum current of 80A/63A/55A (at 2.5V/3.2V/3.65V)
  • Maximum AC charge power 1'560W
  • AC Charging from 20% – 80% in 165min
  • Maximum DC charge power 360W
  • MultiPlus self-power consumption 10W

The Build

As mentioned before, due to space constraints I had to split the battery in 2 parts (with each having 4 cells). Instead of using utz RAKO boxes I used 12mm (sanded) plywood which I did not screw together but tied down with a banding/tensioning tool and a ratchet strap. With this setup, I can easily access und disassemble the cells if needed, while still having a sturdy case. Both cell blocks are connected with a (blue) Anderson SB175 connector.

The BMS itself is mounted to the side of one of the cases (I took extra care to use short screws, in order not to drill into the cell casing). I used M6 Weidmüller 35mm2 90° angled compression cable lug to get the wire away from the BMS and into the bus bar. All other compression cable lugs are DIN 46235 from Klauke (M6 35mm2 on the cells, and M8 16mm2/35mm2 on the bus bar).

The AC and DC wires are all Eland H07RN-F (except for the last two points):

  • Charger to bus bar, battery to bus bar: 35mm2
  • Cell block to cell block: 2 * 35mm2
  • Alternator to DC-DC converter, DC-DC converter to bus bar: 16mm2
  • External AC in to RCBO, RCBO to inverter/charger (both directions), RCBO to internal AC out: 3G2.5mm2
  • For the balancer cables on the cell blocks I used WAGO 221 inline splicing connectors with levers and bullet connectors with 2.5mm2 wire and M6 ring terminals.
  • For the connection of the Inverter/charger to the bus bar, I used the Victron installed 25mm2 welding cables.

Images

The installation is barely visible behind the seats
View from the back with preliminary wiring
Connection of cell blocks with SB175 connectors, cell block 2 and DC-DC converter
Lynx Distributor with cell block 1
Inverter/charger with space for second charger and cell block 2 (left)

Note: the Phoenix charger is not visible on the images, as I am still waiting for it to be delivered.

Charging via EVSE

Conclusion

We now have more than 7'000Wh of additional energy without losing any storage space for roughly 2'850 CHF/2’500 GBP (parts without labour). We can survive an extended weekend of 72h without recharging while still being able to enjoy amenities as using a coffee machine, heating and refrigerator. In case of longer periods of usage, we can recharge at any EVSE, or via shore power. And in emergencies, we can also charge via our Honda EU10i or via the alternator of the vehicle.

The battery is placed directly over the engine which helps in cold weather conditions to easily warm up the batteries to a chargeable level.

The installation can be monitored via Bluetooth (Victron Connect and JK-BMS app).